Jump to content

12" HP 2530P + GTX560Ti@2Gbps+c-EC1 (PE4H 2.4) + Win7 [nando4]


Recommended Posts

[Started 8-14-2011 as *HP EliteBook 2530p Owners Lounge* (NBR). Relocated to T|I due to being banned by Lenovo fan ZaZ]

Implementation: [email protected] 12" HP 2530P + NVidia GTX560Ti/[email protected]
 

Notebook
 
DIY eGPU parts
 
Benchmarks L9400 has some results being higher due to 285.27 and 270.61 modded driver L9600 and L9400 testing variation respectively.

[highest - GTX560Ti: 3dmark: 06/vant.gpu/11.gpu=14248/14151/3391, RE5.dx9=94.6, dmcv4.dx10_s4=131.9].
[highest - GTX460..: 3dmark: 06/vant.gpu/11.gpu=14051/12889/3384, RE5.dx9=91.3, dmcv4.dx10_s4=129.4].
 
LCD
config
CPU
RAM
GPU
DX9
DX10
DX11
Ports
OS
3dmk6~
RE5
var|fixed
FFXIV
Mafia2^!
1080p
3dmk~
vant.g
dmcv4^
scene4
3dmk11
720p
Unigine
Heaven
Dirt2#^
1080p
1080p
720p
External
+25%
pci-e
L9600
@2.90

4.0GB
GTX560Ti
x1.Opt
13882
14064 &
86.9|43.1 
91.7 &|43.6 & 
2976 
3024 &
3288
3291 &
46.4
49.9
11868
12874 &
115.41 
124.29 &
2810
2992 &
1246
1333 &
28.7/44.5
32.2/47.1 &33.5/47.9
ICH9M Win7
64b
External
+25%
pci-e
GTX460
x1.Opt
13607 &
13733 &
85.3 &|42.5 &
86.9 &|43.5 &
2453 
2504
3087
3224
39.6 &42.6
43.0 &46.7
9870 &
10268 &
101.96 &
111.96 &
2483 &
2518 &
965 &
1009 &
22.2/37.2 &26.2/39.2
28.9/41.9 &29.0/42.1
External
+25%
pci-e
L9400
@2.64

4.0GB
12585 &
12688 &
84.0 &|40.6 &
86.5 &|41.1 &
2404 &
2460 &
3039
3071
39.3 &43.6
42.8 &47.6
10081 &
10460 &
103.53 &
106.02 &
2417 &
2479 &
922 &
977 &
25.4/37.5 &26.6/40.7
27.8/40.5 &30.8/43.5
Internal
+25%
pci-e
- 2251 &
2337 &
30.2 &31.3
33.7 &34.1
2367 &
2415 &
587 &
664 &
18.4/26.6 &18.4/27.1
23.5/31.4 &24.3/32.7
^ = 1280x800 with internal LCD, ~ = 1280x1024 with 'internal LCD mode' provided via notebook VGA port to external LCD.
+25% pci-e = overclock the pci-e bus from 100Mhz to 125Mhz | ! = two back-to-back runs using result from the faster second run
& = eGPU overclocked results: GTX460=675/1800->950/1900 GTX460, GTX560Ti=880/2100->1030/2300.
# = min/average, London multi-car track with all HIGH except post-process=MED. cmd used "DiRT2.exe benchmark example_benchmark.xml", output saved to Documents/My Games/Dirt 2/Demo/benchmarks
gtx460pe4hatx.th.jpg 2530pgtx560ti.th.jpg optimusdevices.th.jpg cablingsetup.th.jpg mafiaiiint.th.jpg dirt2ext.th.jpg
US$227 GTX460+
PE4H-EC2C+PSU
Setup 1.x showing system
details + GTX560Ti eGPU
Optimus driver setup PE4H and GTX460 cabling Optimus' internal LCD
mode playing MafiaII
Dirt2 on external LCD


Idea reference: http://forum.techinferno.com/diy-e-gpu-projects/2109-diy-egpu-experiences-%5Bversion-2-0%5D.html#post27126

Software Setup 

1. Boot Win7, sleep Win7, attach eGPU via expresscard slot and power it on, resume Win7. GTX460 is detected as Standard VGA. There are no error 12 or USB ports disabled issues with the 2530P. 

2. Install 285.27 Retrofit Optimus driver. Disable NVidia High Definition sound to maximize video bandwidth. 

3. OPTIONAL for GTX460/GTX560Ti overclocking: Install MSI Afterburner+Kombustor. 

How to startup the eGPU

1. Poweroff the eGPU until get past the bios, then power it on OR set the PE4H PCI Reset Delay slider to 7s to effectively do this automatically for you which works during a cold reboot but not a warm reboot.

OPTIONAL: use sleep-resume method. Boot Win7, sleep Win7, attach eGPU via expresscard slot and power it on, resume Win7. If a LCD is attached to the GTX460 then make it the Main Display in Display Properties to output accelerated graphics to it. NOTE: this method does not allow Optimus to output accelerated graphics to the internal LCD - the eGPU must be detected on bootup for that.

2. Use the Safely Remove Hardware And Eject Media systemtray icon when finished using eGPU.

Comments

I sidegraded to a GTX460 for it's smaller size, quieter operation and significantly lower power requirements while delivering similar real-gaming performance to my previous GTX470. I was surprised to find that with stock 675/1800 clocks this GTX460 can be powered by a basic 12V/15A ATX PSU. Previously I needed two to drive the GTX470. Overclocking's higher power did require a second 12V/15A PSU to supply power via one GTX460 pci-e lead. I don't intend to overclock the GPU during regular use since there aren't any significant real-world gains to be had doing so. Quite content with the GTX460 icon7.gif

The 950/1900 GPU overclock gives about approx 10% more performance with up to 20% more in 3dmarkvantage. The 25% pci-e overclock has a greater real-life effect. When using the internal LCD mode: 3dmark06's SM3.0, RE5-var, Dirt2 all register a solid 20% FPS improvement with smoother rendering with high detail. This would indicate that the x1 2.0 Optimus (x1.2Opt) doubling of bandwidth with the Series-6 systems will mean it's viable to use only the notebook internal LCD with great performance. 

One other observation. When using the internal LCD mode, 3dmarkvantage's texture loading bar was noticably slower to expand even though it wasn't actively changing the screen image. So NVidia allocate a portion of the bandwidth for the internal LCD. Now if NVidia could change their algorithm to maximise usage of the available bandwidth based on load it would improve the internal LCD mode performance.

Is a GTX560Ti worth it over an overclocked GTX460? A GTX560Ti is a 54% price premium over a GTX460, yet you'd see at best 15% more performance with a GTX460 being able to handle a significant overclock. Is then a GTX560Ti worth it? In the case of a x1.Opt link on a 2530P, I think the GTX460 represents much better value.
 


Appendix: other mods/discoveries during this implementation

1. Modified 1GB GTX460 reference bios with fan+voltage unlock

I created a modified GTX460 bios to correct the GTX460 internal thermal throttling as discussed. The source was a Gainward factory 800/2000 overclocked 1GB GTX460 bios modified back to reference 675/1800 clocks, 1.025V Vcore with unlocked fan and voltage control. The result packaged as GTX460_anti-throttle.exe. 

Seems to have done the trick. This also corrected an instability issue which was due to my stock bios being undervolted @0.963V with full 3D clocks.

If you wish to try this vbios then extract the package to c:\GTX460_anti-throttle, run 'flash_it'. You'll need to re-install your NVidia drivers. Run 'reverse' to flash back your original bios if it causes any issues. Ensure you keep a copy of the saved GTX460-original.rom in a safe place in case you need to flash back for warranty purposes.

2. Making a modular PSU from an ATX one

My PSU was AU$5 so it was an easy decision to cut unneeded molex leads in order to tidy up my cabling. Required and unrequired molex leads were noted. Then I used a jeweller's flat screwdriver to remove the pin from the junction-point molex plug, snip off the extra cabling using pliers + nail clippers ensuring a clean cut at the base, then careful put back the pins in the correct order. This way I ended up with a PSU with only 3 molex leads.

3. Quietening the ATX PSU fan by driving it with 5V

My AU$5 PSU had a noisy fan. To quieten it down I changed the fan's +12V line (RED) to use +5V instead. This involved unfastening 8 screws, de-soldering the fan connector and attaching it to a nearby 5V connector. A 5V point was found by attach one multimeter probe to the 5V (RED) molex lead and continuity probing the circuitboard.

Yes.. running the slower fan will mean less heat dissipation and higher internal temps. Not that this has caused any problems so far. Should it happen that my AU$5 PSU fails prematurely then I'll use my other AU$5 one.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.